THIS week’s release of the Strategic Grain Network Committee’s final report into emerging transport infrastructure issues in the export grain supply chain has been cautiously welcomed by MLC member for the Agriculture Region Max Trenorden.
“I congratulate the Minister for Transport on commissioning this committee and the timely delivery of its findings,” he said.
“The report is comprehensive and contains some sound recommendations on the future direction of the transport of grain on rail in this State.”
While Mr Trenorden acknowledged the ink was still drying on the report, he encouraged the minister to maintain momentum.
He said the committee’s work has already proved valuable but expressed concern with some aspects.
“For me there are two clear issues to come from the report,” he said.
“The first is the recommendation to fully reassess the heavy vehicle permit system which has potentially far-reaching implications for local shires.
“One of the committee’s recommendations is the need to look closely at large combination vehicles transporting grain between bins and from bins to port.
“The report suggested their use needs to be limited primarily to areas not covered by rail.
“If we limit these heavy vehicles to certain roads the potential is for local shire roads – the feeder roads – to see increased traffic.
“As the report outlined, there needs to be close consultation between CBH and the local government authority to ensure shires aren’t left to pick up the tab.
“They simply do not have the financial capacity to maintain these roads and I’m asking the minister to clearly outline his intentions in this regard to give shires some peace of mind.”
Mr Trenorden said he also had concerns with the committee’s recommendation to improve rail services covering the south Kwinana region.
He said detailed planning was still needed.
“There is potential from this recommendation for a new line to run from Kwinana to Brookton and possibly to Quairading and Merredin,” he said.
“There is a clear need for this but the Government must be careful not to turn the project into an Ellenbrook-style planning disaster.
“Both the ALP and the Liberal Party have previously championed a rail line from the city out to Ellenbrook but have done so with nothing more than a mud map and a few figures drawn on the back of an envelope.
“This central regional area needs to be serviced by a rail network as it’s both socially and financially unacceptable for grain to be transported on road in the long run.”
Mr Trenorden said if a new network was to be a success then proper consideration was needed.
“I’m again asking the minister to ensure a detailed, costed plan is developed to ensure this new line achieves the outcomes we all know it must,” he concluded
Mr Trenorden was also critical of comments made by the shadow minister Alannah MacTiernan.
“It's irritating that she could have fixed this while she was the minister,” he said.
“She had no difficulty finding $600 million over budget for the Mandurah railway line but she couldn't find $100 million for wheat lines.
“Fares on the Mandurah line are 80 per cent subsidised while the grain lines earn money and she still couldn't find the $100 million.”